Point Cook: A case study in 12 years of government infrastructure failures as polls show support for Labor collapsing

on

A generation of children has grown up watching their parents petition governments for better roads, healthcare and community facilities. Now, many of those children are eligible to vote. And Labour MP Mathew Hilakari faces the challenger Liberal candidate Raja Ramesh Reddy asking some difficult questions in defending his government’s record.

Twelve years ago, when Daniel Andrews swept Labor back into government in Victoria, Point Cook was a suburb full of dreams and aspirations.

Thousands of Indian, Chinese, Filipino and other migrant families were buying their first Australian homes, establishing businesses, building professional careers and dreaming of a better future for their children.

Alamanda College, which opened in 2013 with just 371 students, was becoming the educational centre of those aspirations.

Children who entered Year 1 in 2014 are now reaching voting age. Those who have turned 18 and are Australian citizens will be eligible to vote in the Victorian state election on 28 November.

An entire generation has grown up under successive Labor governments, witnessing the consequences of infrastructure delivery failing to keep pace with residential development.

For many families, childhood memories include waiting at childcare centres while their parents were stuck in traffic on Point Cook Road, travelling outside the suburb for swimming lessons and crossing the freeway to access sporting and recreational facilities.

Point Cook Community Growth; Image Source: AI-generated editorial illustration by The Australia Today from supplied material

Their parents have spent years signing petitions, attending community meetings and approaching elected representatives, demanding basic infrastructure.

Yet, 12 years later, several of those demands remain unresolved.

Point Cook’s population increased from 32,413 in 2011 to 49,929 in 2016 and 66,781 in 2021. By 2026, local estimates put the population at approximately 70,000.

The population growth was predictable. The infrastructure shortages were documented. The community’s demands were repeatedly communicated.

Point Cook Road has become perhaps the most visible example of delayed infrastructure investment.

As early as November 2018, Wyndham City Council identified the duplication of Point Cook Road between Sneydes Road and Dunnings Road as a critical infrastructure requirement.

Residents repeatedly warned that residential development without corresponding road improvements would make their daily lives increasingly difficult.

A community petition launched in November 2019 demanded action on traffic congestion. That same year, 7NEWS reported the experience of a local father who was spending 40 minutes travelling just five kilometres to reach the freeway.

On 7 November 2022, then Hobsons Bay Mayor Peter Hemphill confirmed in an official council media release that the council had been advocating for the duplication of Point Cook Road for two decades.

That means the people’s advocacy dates back to approximately 2002, nearly 24 years ago.

Labor secured another term in government, but the broader road duplication remained unresolved.

Fast-forward to September 2026, and Premier Ben Carroll announced another election commitment, promising $195 million to widen a two-kilometre section of Point Cook Road between Central Avenue and Dunnings Road.

Planning is expected to begin in 2027, subject to Labor being returned to government.

However, some long-term residents are questioning both the timing and practicality of the announcement.

Robert Due, a Point Cook resident who has lived in the area since 1990, said that residents had been demanding the road duplication since the beginning of the century.

Robert questioned the timing of the announcement, saying the commitment would have been far more meaningful had it been made 25 years earlier.

He questioned whether the development of businesses, schools and surrounding properties over the intervening years had made the proposed widening considerably more difficult.

His comments raise questions about successive governments’ infrastructure priorities, particularly given Labor’s uninterrupted tenure since 2014.

Road congestion, however, is only one part of Point Cook’s infrastructure backlog.

Despite having approximately 70,000 residents, the suburb still does not have its own council-operated public swimming pool.

For a community located near the coast and surrounded by waterways, the absence of a public aquatic centre has been a longstanding concern for families.

In 2021, Point Cook Action Group secretary Christine Macpherson told Star Weekly that residents had already been campaigning for an aquatic centre for at least a decade.

“We feel it’s very much overdue,” Macpherson said.

She had previously made a submission to Wyndham City Council’s budget in 2018, advocating for a swimming pool or indoor recreational facility.

In 2019, Wyndham Council allocated $50,000 to investigate demand for aquatic facilities in Point Cook and Williams Landing.

By June 2026, councillors were commissioning another assessment, with a report expected in March 2027.

Years of advocacy, budget submissions and feasibility work have yet to deliver the public swimming pool residents have been seeking.

Community frustration intensified when it emerged that approximately $36 million in historic developer contributions collected through Point Cook’s residential development remained in council accounts.

Residents argued that the funds should be used to address infrastructure shortages within the suburb.

Instead, Wyndham City Council decided in 2025 to allocate approximately $24.4 million towards a regional community events facility without guaranteeing that it would be located in Point Cook.

More than 1,300 valid signatures were collected through a petition opposing the decision.

Point Cook resident Dwayne Kelly, who helped lead the campaign, questioned the fairness of redirecting money collected through the development of the suburb.

“If we look at this ethically, it doesn’t pass the pub test,” Kelly told ABC News in June 2025.

His concerns extended beyond the funding decision itself. Kelly wanted residents to understand how infrastructure contributions collected in their community were being allocated and why their suburb continued to lack essential facilities.

Sporting organisations have also experienced the consequences of insufficient infrastructure.

Kate Coffey, from the Altona Basketball Association, told ABC News that children from Wyndham were travelling to neighbouring areas because of the shortage of indoor basketball courts.

“We just don’t have the court space, and there’s lots of kids from Wyndham coming here,” she said.

While different levels of government disputed responsibility, residents continued to wait.

Healthcare provides another example of the time taken to deliver infrastructure in Melbourne’s growing west.

The Victorian government announced funding for the Point Cook Community Hospital in October 2018.

Major construction began seven years after the announcement in mid-2025, with the Victorian Health Building Authority scheduling completion of major construction for 2027.

Approximately nine years will have passed between the original funding announcement and the scheduled completion of major construction.

In the meantime, residents have relied heavily on Werribee Mercy Hospital, which was identified as the lowest-rated facility among 126 Australian public hospitals examined in an October 2026 analysis of Google reviews.

As previously reported by The Australia Today, the hospital received an average rating of 2.19 out of five from 1,233 reviews.

The Victorian Government has invested in expanding Werribee Mercy Hospital’s emergency department, but questions remain about whether healthcare investment has adequately kept pace with population growth.

These longstanding infrastructure concerns have now become a political challenge for Hilakari as he campaigns to retain Point Cook.

His latest election announcements include the possibility of a railway connection to the suburb.

In a Facebook campaign video published during the final weeks of the election campaign, Hilakari announced:

“Labor will invest in a feasibility study for the Point Cook rail project and an east-west transport corridor at the southern end of Point Cook to connect to the Werribee Train Line.”

For residents accustomed to waiting years for infrastructure, the distinction between a feasibility study and a construction commitment is particularly important.

Labor has not committed to building a railway line into Point Cook. It has committed to investigating its feasibility.

The published announcement contains no funding figure for the study, no construction budget, no confirmed railway alignment, no proposed station locations and no completion date.

If the duplication of an existing road has remained unresolved for years, how long could residents expect to wait for an entirely new railway?

Why was such a study not commissioned earlier, when the suburb’s population growth and transport challenges were already apparent?

The questions surrounding Labor’s infrastructure record have become more pressing as statewide opinion polls reveal a substantial decline in support for the government.

The latest The Australia Today multicultural voter survey in collaboration with six multicultural organisations between 5 and 13 November found that Labor was trailing the Liberal-National Coalition among the 1,486 respondents surveyed across Victoria.

The Coalition secured 37 per cent support, followed by Labor at 24 per cent, One Nation at 23 per cent, the Greens at 11 per cent and five per cent choosing none of the above.

For Point Cook, the findings highlight the electoral challenges facing Labor among the multicultural voters surveyed, a demographic that has traditionally formed an important part of its support base in Melbourne’s western suburbs.

An October Newspoll also recorded a statewide two-party-preferred result of 55 per cent for the Coalition and 45 per cent for Labor.

Point Cook was created largely from the former electorate of Altona, which Labor had held throughout its 30-year existence.

At the 2022 state election, Hilakari secured approximately 40 per cent of first-preference votes, a decline of 9.7 percentage points compared with Labor’s estimated performance on equivalent boundaries in 2018.

Although he retained the seat with 58.3 per cent of the two-candidate-preferred vote, the decline in primary support demonstrated that Labor’s historical dominance was not immune to electoral change.

Challenging Hilakari at this election is Liberal candidate Raja Ramesh Reddy, a long-term local resident, small business owner and community organiser.

Reddy has lived in the area for more than two decades and is raising his family locally.

As president of Wyndham Diwali and through his involvement in community activities, Reddy has established connections with local families, businesses and community organisations.

He previously contested the neighbouring electorate of Laverton at the 2022 state election.

Reddy is campaigning on a commitment to listen to residents and work with the community to address local concerns, arguing that successive Labor governments have taken Melbourne’s western suburbs for granted.

Speaking to The Australia Today during the election campaign, Reddy said he was “out in our community every day listening to locals”.

He has identified community safety, household expenses and the pressures facing local businesses as key concerns.

In his election statement, Reddy also highlighted the Coalition’s proposed $50 weekly toll cap, recruitment of additional police officers and stronger sentencing laws.

Reddy’s campaign presents a local alternative to Hilakari, although the Liberals must also demonstrate how they intend to fund and deliver the infrastructure projects residents have been demanding.

Specific funding commitments and delivery timelines for a Point Cook aquatic centre and the remaining road duplication would provide residents with a clearer basis for assessing those promises.

The Point Cook Action Group has again outlined its priorities ahead of the 2026 election, calling for better public transport, healthcare, recreational facilities, community safety and employment opportunities closer to home.

Its demands are being made to all political parties, underscoring that the community’s infrastructure needs extend beyond partisan politics.

Labor defended its record, pointing to intersection improvements, new schools, specialist education facilities, the Point Cook Community Hospital and the expansion of Werribee Mercy Hospital’s emergency department.

Those investments are part of the government’s record, but so are the delays and infrastructure shortages that residents have experienced.

Point Cook’s story raises a broader question about the consequences of governments failing to match infrastructure investment with population growth, particularly in electorates that have historically provided reliable electoral support.

For years, residents attempted to influence decisions through petitions, community campaigns, council submissions and representations to their elected members.

The children whose parents were campaigning for better roads and community facilities when Labor returned to government are now becoming adults.

Some will enter a polling booth for the first time on 28 November.

Their experiences provide a generational perspective on the infrastructure decisions made over the past 12 years.

Polls show that Hilakari is failing to convince residents that his government’s latest commitments will translate into completed projects.

For Reddy and the other candidates, the challenge is to demonstrate that their alternatives offer more than another set of election promises.

After 12 years of Labor government, Point Cook offers a case study in the gap between acknowledging a community’s needs and meeting them.

The infrastructure problems are well documented. The petitions are on record. The latest promises have been made.

What remains to be established is when residents will finally go to the polls and whom they will trust.

Support our Journalism

No-nonsense journalism. No paywalls. Whether you’re in Australia, the UK, Canada, the USA, or India, you can support The Australia Today by taking a paid subscription via Patreon or donating via PayPal — and help keep honest, fearless journalism alive.

Add a little bit of body text 8 1 1