John Cleese backs Sikh restaurateur targeted by Islamists over serving non-halal meat in London

on

A British-Sikh restaurant owner’s decision not to serve halal meat should never become grounds for intimidation, threats or attempts to shut down his business. Yet Harman Singh Kapoor, owner of Singh’s Dining in Hammersmith, west London, has found himself at the centre of a bitter confrontation after his establishment openly declared that it does not sell halal food.

Hundreds gathered outside the restaurant on November 13, demanding its closure, prompting a significant police presence and the deployment of private security. British actor and comedian John Cleese has publicly backed Kapoor, bringing renewed attention to a controversy that goes far beyond one restaurant. At its heart is a fundamental question: does an individual in Britain still have the freedom to make lawful personal, commercial and religious choices without facing intimidation?

The principle should be uncontroversial. A restaurant owner has every right to decide what food to sell, just as customers have every right to decide where they eat. An establishment can proudly advertise that it serves halal food; another can just as legitimately declare that it does not. A Muslim-owned restaurant cannot be compelled to sell pork, just as a Hindu-owned establishment cannot be forced to serve beef. Equally, a Sikh restaurateur should not be pressured into selling halal meat against his convictions. Freedom of choice cannot operate in only one direction. Consumers who disagree are free to take their business elsewhere, but they cannot dictate the lawful commercial decisions of another individual.

The November 13 demonstration raises serious concerns about using religiously charged mobilisation to pressure a business owner. Videos from the gathering showed protesters chanting slogans including “Allahu Akbar”, “Shame on you” and “Free Palestine”, while Palestinian flags were visible. Some demanded that the restaurant close. The dispute apparently is not exclusively about halal food: protesters have also accused Kapoor of making derogatory remarks about Muslims, Muhammad (Prophet of Islam) and the Gaza conflict through social media. But in a free society neither offensive speech nor disagreement with religious beliefs gives anyone the right to threaten or intimidate a family. Kapoor, on the other hand, has said that he and his family have endured repeated death threats, harassment and threats of sexual violence, allegations that require proper investigation.

The Metropolitan Police’s handling of the situation also deserves scrutiny. While it remains unclear whether police investigated the threats against Kapoor, officers instead arrested him at his home on November 13 on suspicion of possessing and distributing an extreme image. Kapoor has said he repeatedly sought police protection but received an inadequate response, leaving him fearing for his family’s safety ahead of the planned demonstration outside his restaurant. Harmans’s wife Khushi Kapoor has publicly said that her family needs round-the-clock private security because she no longer trusts the Metropolitan Police. She also questioned whether police had arrested the individual she accused of encouraging other Muslims to kill her husband, Tommy Robinson and John Cleese.

Cleese’s intervention is especially significant given his own history of challenging religious sensitivities through comedy. The Monty Python star, best known for Fawlty Towers and Monty Python’s Life of Brian, has publicly supported Kapoor. The restaurant owner’s wife, Khushi Kapoor, thanked Cleese for helping arrange private security during the demonstration. Cleese subsequently said that a private citizen had paid for the security, without explicitly confirming that he was personally the individual who funded it. His support has nevertheless brought an international spotlight to the dispute. Life of Brian, released in 1979, satirised religious authority and messianic beliefs, provoking considerable controversy among Christian groups. Despite attempts to restrict it, the film became an enduring example of the place of religious satire in a free society.

Britain has, however, faced a very different challenge when artistic expression has touched upon Islam. The contrast is worth examining. In 2022, The Lady of Heaven, a film about Fatima, the daughter of Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam, became the subject of protests outside cinemas after some Muslim activists condemned it as blasphemous. The film controversially used computer-generated imagery to represent Muhammed’s face. Following demonstrations at several venues, major cinema chain Cineworld cancelled all its UK screenings, explicitly citing safety concerns. The decision effectively removed the film from Cineworld’s nationwide programme, although rival chain Vue continued showing it at some locations. There was no formal nationwide government ban, but the outcome demonstrated how protests and the threat of disorder can determine what audiences are permitted to see. When the prospect of intimidation is enough to make a major cinema chain withdraw a legally classified film, freedom of artistic expression is seriously compromised.

The same principle applies to criticism of religion. In a free country, people must be able to question religious doctrines, criticise religious institutions, challenge practices and satirise figures considered sacred by believers. That freedom must extend equally to Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Sikhism, Judaism and every other faith. People are entitled to take offence, disagree and organise peaceful protests. They are not entitled to demand immunity from criticism or use threats and intimidation to silence those who disagree.

Criticism of Islam is not automatically hatred of Muslims, just as criticism of Christianity or Hinduism is not hatred of Christians or Hindus. This distinction is fundamental to a genuinely pluralistic democracy. Religious beliefs deserve the same freedom to be expressed as they do to be challenged.

Yet there appears to be a growing reluctance to apply this principle consistently. Criticism of other religions and of religious or cultural practices is commonplace in Western media and academia, while many seem to walk on eggshells when it comes to Islam or certain practices within Muslim communities. One striking example is that despite established scientific evidence of increased genetic risks to children born to first-cousin couples, the UK Government has yet to commit to supporting legislation to prohibit first-cousin marriages. The First Cousins (Prohibited Relationships) Bill was introduced by Conservative MP Dr Luke Evans on 17 June 2026, but the Government says it is still considering whether legislation is the best way to address the issue, rather than education and community engagement. If the increased health risks are acknowledged, what further consideration does the Government need before taking a clear position on legislation?

Research has documented significant health and developmental concerns associated with consanguineous marriages. The landmark 2013 Born in Bradford study, published in The Lancet, found that children born to first-cousin couples faced a 2.19-fold risk of congenital anomalies compared with children of unrelated parents — an increase of approximately 120%. The study also found that 37% of Pakistani-origin babies in its Bradford cohort had parents who were first cousins, and that consanguinity could account for 31% of congenital anomalies among children of Pakistani origin.

Separately, the UK Department for Education’s 2018 analysis of learning disabilities found that Pakistani-heritage children had identification rates at least 25% above the national average across three categories: moderate, severe and profound multiple learning difficulties. A 2024 follow-up study of the Born in Bradford cohort also found higher rates of learning difficulties among children of first-cousin unions. These findings highlight the importance of examining the health and developmental implications of close-relative marriages.

Similarly, in coverage of the grooming-gang scandal by Pakistani Muslim men, there were concerns that sections of the media and public debate sought to obscure the specific background of the perpetrators by referring to them more broadly as Asian or South Asian men.

Of course, criticising a practice within a community does not mean suggesting that every member of that community engages in it. When racism is discussed, nobody adds this caveat that not all white people are racist, that is obviously understood. The same must apply when examining harmful practices within particular communities: criticism of those practices is not an accusation against every member of the community. But neither should that distinction be used to shut down legitimate scrutiny or make criticism taboo.

Increasingly, there are concerns that Islamists are seeking to silence critics not only in the UK but across the Western world, misusing hate-speech laws to intimidate or penalise those who challenge religious beliefs and practices. The danger is that, under the guise of protecting religious sensitivities, they are attempting to impose a de facto Sharia-style blasphemy code on Western societies. In a free democracy, no religion or ideology should be beyond scrutiny, and no group should have the power to dictate what others are allowed to say about it. There are also questions about government funding for some organisations through multicultural grants, including whether taxpayers’ money is being used to silence critics or, more alarmingly, reaching organisations linked to radicalisation.

Britain, and indeed the wider Western world, must confront increasingly urgent questions about threats to free speech, attempts by Islamists to financially ruin critics through legal action, the use of taxpayer-funded resources to pursue such cases, and, more alarmingly, the threat or use of violence to silence dissent. It must also scrutinise whether public institutions are fulfilling their responsibility to protect freedom of expression, a fundamental right under the law.

If a business owner cannot decide what food to sell, an artist cannot create work that challenges religious sensitivities and an ordinary citizen cannot criticise a faith without fearing retaliation, what remains of freedom of expression? The police have a duty to protect everyone equally, not to allow the prospect of disorder to determine whose rights are upheld. No religion should have a veto over lawful business decisions, public debate or artistic expression. A free society cannot promise people that they will never be offended. It must promise that they will not be intimidated into surrendering their freedoms.

Support our Journalism

No-nonsense journalism. No paywalls. Whether you’re in Australia, the UK, Canada, the USA, or India, you can support The Australia Today by taking a paid subscription via Patreon or donating via PayPal — and help keep honest, fearless journalism alive.

Add a little bit of body text 8 1 1