Canada long claimed to be a bastion of multiculturalism and inclusivity, is grappling with an alarming rise in hate crimes and violence against its Indian and Hindu communities. This disturbing trend calls into question the nation’s commitment to being a safe place for immigrants and highlights significant challenges in maintaining its reputation as a welcoming destination.
Alarming Increase in Hate Crimes
According to a new report by the Centre for Integrated and Holistic Studies (CIHS), recent years have witnessed a surge in hate crimes targeting Indians and Hindus in Canada.
These incidents range from physical assaults to threats and vandalism of religious sites, such as the 2017 Calgary attack where an Indian man was assaulted with a baseball bat while enduring racial slurs. Such events starkly contradict Canada’s historical image as a sanctuary for immigrants and undermine the safety and security of these communities.
Unchecked Extremism and Law Enforcement Challenges
The CIHS report underscores the free operation of Khalistani extremists in Canada, who have been involved in intimidating Hindu minorities and desecrating temples. The vandalism of a Hindu temple in British Columbia in January 2023, where pro-Khalistan posters were found, exemplifies this issue. These extremist groups not only threaten physical safety but also erode the perception of Canada as a secure and inclusive country.
Concerns have been raised about the efficacy of Canadian law enforcement in addressing these threats. The response to anti-Hindu and anti-India sentiments has often been criticised as inadequate, further straining diplomatic relations with India. The Canadian government’s handling of protests and rallies by Khalistani radicals has come under scrutiny, particularly in light of their potential to incite violence and terrorism.
Factors Contributing to Decline in Safety
Several factors contribute to the deteriorating safety of Indians and Hindus in Canada:
- Hate Speech on Social Media: Platforms have become breeding grounds for hate speech, xenophobic discourse, and extremist ideologies, which fuel hostility against minorities.
- Political and Racial Motivations: Incidents like the Calgary attack highlight how racism and political extremism intersect, creating a volatile environment for targeted communities.
- Inadequate Law Enforcement Response: Victims often feel marginalised by law enforcement agencies, leading to under-reporting of crimes and a lower standard of accountability for offenders.
The Multifaceted Threat of Extremist Groups
Khalistani and Jihadi extremists pose multi-dimensional dangers, including:
- Hate Crimes: Physical assaults and vandalism targeting Indian and Hindu communities.
- Online Harassment: Increased online abuse and threats aimed at individuals based on their ethnicity or religion.
- Protests and Rallies: Organised demonstrations that disrupt diplomatic visits and cultural events, spreading misinformation and inciting violence.
- Pressure Tactics: Threats against businesses, local authorities, or politicians who oppose extremism or defend the rights of Indian or Hindu communities.
Criticism of Government Response
The Canadian government’s response to these issues has been criticised for being insufficient and, at times, counterproductive. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s administration has permitted rallies by Khalistani radicals, drawing comparisons to the tragic Kanishka bombing. Despite India’s repeated requests to curb such activities, citing the right to free speech has led to questions about Canada’s stance on terrorism and extremism.
Economic and Social Impacts
The rise in hate crimes and extremist activities poses significant economic and social risks. The fear and insecurity felt by Indian and Hindu communities affect their daily lives, including their ability to study, work, and contribute to society. This undermines the economic contributions these communities make to Canada, which has historically benefited from their diversity and talent.
Proactive Measures for Inclusivity
To counter the rise in hate crimes and promote inclusivity, Canada must adopt proactive measures:
- Intelligence Sharing: Collaborate with international partners, including India, to share intelligence on extremist activities.
- Strengthen Law Enforcement: Enhance the capacity of law enforcement agencies to respond to hate crimes and extremism effectively.
- Promote Diversity and Inclusion: Implement policies and programs that foster a more inclusive society, celebrating the contributions of all communities.
- Diplomatic Outreach: Engage in diplomatic efforts to address shared concerns and advance global security.
Canada’s reputation as a model of tolerance and multiculturalism is at stake. The rise in hate crimes and violence against Indians and Hindus demands urgent action. By addressing the root causes of racism and intolerance and adopting concrete steps to combat hate crimes, Canada can reaffirm its dedication to diversity and ensure a safe and respected environment for all citizens.
The CIHS report calls for a balanced approach that upholds the right to free speech while prioritising the safety and security of individuals and diplomatic missions. Allowing radical organisations to hold protests is an affront to democratic values and sends a misguided signal to those who engage in violent and extremist acts.
Canada must take a firm stand against terrorism and extremist ideologies, ensuring the safety of all residents and protecting its multicultural heritage.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s administration must choose between supporting international relations and combating terrorism to advance Canada’s interests and uphold its principles. Collaboration with India on countering extremism, sharing best practices, and ensuring a unified response to global threats is essential for maintaining peace and security in both nations.
Support Our Journalism
‘Global Indian Diaspora and Australia’s multicultural communities need fair, non-hyphenated, and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. The Australia Today – with exceptional reporters, columnists, and editors – is doing just that. Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.
Whether you live in Australia, the United Kingdom, Canada, the United States of America, or India you can take a paid subscription by clicking Patreon and support honest and fearless journalism.
